UK Piano Page Piano Forum
Piano Forums at UK Piano Page, feel free to read the posts on our piano forums. If you wish to reply to a post or submit a new post you must register first, it's free.
Please read the Piano Forum FAQ for more details. Also, read the piano FAQ for common questions on pianos Please don't ask us to place a value on your piano as an on site inspection is required. Contact you local piano tuner who will be more than happy to help.
I generally always prefer the sound of the German pianos, much warmer and richer - I agree with you that Yamaha and Japanese pianos are brighter in tone, and this is obviously a personal choice.
I am only stating my opinion here! Of course at the end of the day, the piano is going to be sitting in your room and you are going to be the one playing it - so the best advice would be to go with your instincts.
You can normally tell very quickly whether you like a piano, and whether it sounds better than one you have previously played.... good luck with it!
It is very easy to be lured into buying a Yamaha (Before there are any horrible comments, I am not saying that buying a Yamaha is wrong or that Yamaha pianos are rubbish) because of the discounting on them. You can quite easily buy a 7'0" Yamaha for the same price as another manufacturers 5'11" piano. Now this is not to say that this is not a good offer, but when spending the amount of money you are considering (RRP Schimmel K169T is around £20,995), you almost need to forget the cost and just concentrate on the 2 most important factors - touch and tone!
Sorry, rant over!
I have only one gripe with Schimmels they take a lot of tunings to settle in but nice when they do. Having said that for me with £25K to spend
Web Master UK Piano Page
If you think Japanese pianos are 'very bright' then go to another dealer. There's absolutely no reason at all why a properly set-up and voiced Yamaha won't sound every bit as good as the Schimmel. They're terribly overpriced, and depreciation is vertical. The Vogel range is good value and uses the best bits from Schimmel at a lower price (but I think they're made in Poland Barrie, and possibly the only decent piano ever to emerge from that country).sybre wrote:Hi, does anyone have any opinion on the Schimmel K169T grand piano? I tried it and i like it, I actually want to get a Yamaha Grand but i feel Japanese pianos are very bright and i want to get a more mellow sounding piano. Are Schimmel pianos generally good?
What size piano do you need? If you're in Schimmel territory I'd go for a Yam S6 (the only sensible alternative to a Steinway B) and be done with it. If you're looking on a more modest budget, a C3 is excellent value. Just don't buy it from a 'pile it high, sell it cheap' merchant, and try the piano you intend buying, not merely a similar one.
As for tuning stability, I agree 100% with Barrie. Schimmels take an age to settle down. Once they're there, they're fine.
I agree with PianoGuy.
Of course I have many many clients who have quality German pianos and in many cases I can see the appeal of the various instruments, but all of them require more of my time and my clients' money than they would if they had selected from the list above. I don't mind of course!
If a European piano* really captures your heart, gets your mojo working and creative juices flowing, then it's obviously the piano for you, but in 99% of cases, it will mean more attention from a good technician and more regular tuning to keep it that way than if you had gone for the Yamaha.
There are however, many models of Yamaha which are just as capricious as their European counterparts!! The S4 is the most notable; it sounds absolutely gorgeous when just tuned, but I've yet to find one where the tuning lasts more than a month. The very limited edition S400 was even better sounding when in tune, but a few days or even hours later and it starts to howl.
*Except of course those from Poland and the Czech Republic. They're still shite.
Like PG said, if a Yamaha's properly voiced there's no reason why it shouldn't sound as mellow as a weekend in an Amsterdam brown cafe.
The hard bit, in my experience, is finding a dealer who will take the trouble to do it.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests